Key Crit!!
- Created by: melanielouise77
- Created on: 22-01-20 09:34
Carey-Webb: Colonisation
"a model of colonial relationships and a metaphor of colonial history"
- Prospero's treatment of Caliban
- Trinculo and Stephano's treatment of Caliban
Goodwin: Hidden meanings
"A great deal of its substance seems deliberately hidden beneath the surface.”
- Prospero's manipulation of Miranda and Ferdinand's relationship
- The Masque
Hirst: Power
"The Tempest is a play about power"
- Prospero's desire for power
- Trinculo and Stephano's desire for power
- Prospero's control over Miranda
- Prospero's control over Caliban
- Stephano and Trinculo's control over Caliban
Knott: Ending/Monologue
"Prospero's tragic monologue"
- he has changed and become a New Testament God
- links to Shakespeare: his last play, saying goodbye to theatre
Billington: Cards (Prospero's power)
"Prospero holds all the cards"
- Prospero has control over everyone/everything
Vaughn: Colonisation
"Europeans control the land, its resources, its inhabitants: a theatrical microcosm of the imperial paradigm"
- Prospero's control over Caliban
- Stephano and Trinculo's control over Caliban
Mendes: Sub-plot
You get a sense of the sub-plot echoing the main plot, parodying those other characters. Their purpose in the play is important.”
- Trinculo and Stephano's attempted usurpation of Prospero mirrors Antonio and Sebastian's attempted usurpation of Alonso.
Hargest: Sub-plot
"To present Stefano, the drunken butler and Trinculo, the court jester merely as a pair of drunken clowns is to oversimplify their roles"
The sub-plot allows Shakespeare to "reinforce the dark, conspiratorial world of the play, and emphasise the important themes of the master-servant relationship and the elusive nature of power and freedom."
- mirrors and parodies the main plot
- criticism of colonisation
Jameson: Miranda's ignorance
"total ignorance of the conventional forms and language of society"
- carries the logs for Ferdinand
- tries to stand up for him (asks him to be gentle/not to hurt him)
- rebels against the conventional ideas of Jacobean women
Billington: Colonisation
Prospero can be seen as a "colonial overlord"
- Treatment of Caliban reflect the colonisers' treatment of the natives.
Linley: Surface
"The Tempest appears at first sight a light-hearted mix of romance and playful humour, but it is also dark at times, cynical, satirical, violent and psychologically disturbing, hinting deep character flaws and suspect motives."
- Stephano and Trinculo's attemtped usurpation and manipulation of Caliban
- Prospero's manipulation and control over Miranda (the Masque)
Doran: Revenge and Forgiveness
The Tempest is a play about "the human desire for revenge and our capacity for forgiveness."
- Prospero's journey of redemption and forgiveness (shift from Old Testament to New Testament God)
- Epilogue
Herrin: Redemption and Forgiveness
The Tempest is a play "about forgiveness and the possibility of redemption."
- Prospero's shift from Old testament to New Testament God
- Epilogue
Mabillard: Forgiveness
"Prospero goes through the motions of forgiveness, but his sincerity is lost to us."
- Manipulation to regain his power
- Epilogue
Linley and Solomon: Old to New
"The Prospero of Acts I-IV represents the stern Old Testament God - harsh, vengeful and punitive . . . . Prospero’s planned revenge, turns at the end to the central idea of the New Testament: forgiveness."
"Prospero undergoes a transformation."
- Prospero's arguable forgiveness
- Shift from Old to New Testament God
Knight: Ariel and Caliban to Prospero
"Ariel and Caliban are representations of dual minor potentialities of Prospero's soul."
- Caliban is a parallel --> shows his darker side of human nature
- Ariel is a foil --> shows his brighter side of human nature
Kermode: Old to New
"Learning is a major theme in the play"
- Prospero's shift from Old Testament to New Testament God (more forgiving)
Mowat: Epilogue
"The final image of Prospero that lingers in our minds is of the mortal creature of the epilogue."
- demonstrates Prospero's shift over the course of the play
Linely: Masque and control
"The ideal control, imaged in snow and fire, is sustained throughout the masque."
- Prospero uses the Masque as a demonstration of his power
- Using Miranda and Ferdinand's marriage as a way of gaining power
Related discussions on The Student Room
- OCR A Level English Lit... how do I get good?! (yr13) »
- A-Level English literature essays »
- Eduqas A-level English Literature Component 1 (A720U10-1) - 24th May 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- Resources for A-level English Lit OCR? »
- AQA English Language Paper 2 Question 2 Exemplar Answer »
- A-level English Lit - The Tempest Part A and B »
- Crits »
- English lit students (a level and uni) help! »
- OCR A Level The Tempest »
- ocr english lit a level help »
Comments
No comments have yet been made