It makes moral obligation appear arbitrary but there are many factors which can rightly influnce our decision making.
What do you do with two absolute conflict; Always tell the truth and Always keep your promises. A Nazis soldier comes in and ask you to tell him where the Jewish family is concealed. Do you tell the truth or keep your promise?
Reason can not be guaranteed to lead people to the same conclusion. Also Kant assumes everybody is able to use reason to make moral decision.
How far can a good motive or goodwill justify an action? Goodwill can cause chaos and motivation itself cannot undo the damage.
W.D.Ross - Question the Prima-facie duties, as some people have a duties that must override their duties to others.
Comments
No comments have yet been made