Link between previous life & person who inherited the soul = problematic
Reincarnation suggests that memory or physical body not the link between the two = so what is?
If soul (which does not include memory), then what does it mean to say that the soul survives?
Swinburne rejects reincarnation:
If no continuity btwn brain of new baby & old person who died, then no way of saying that soul is distinctively of a particular person.
If no link btwn reincarnated soul & old body which it was in, then what is meant by karma being carried forward & atman reincarnated?
Doctrine of Karma explains suffering - happens because of sins in past lives.
Stephen Davis = person with reincarnated atman, has no memory of sins committed because link is only immaterial soul, so why being punished for something a different person has done?
Peter Geach no link established between person who died - no evidence of new reincarnated person being the old dead person - lacks body, memories, experiences, feelings etc?
Comments
No comments have yet been made