Comparison of direct and representative democracy
- Advantages of direct democracy: it is the purest form of democracy, avoids decisions being made by representatives purely in their own interests, people are becoming increasingly informed and educated so can make their own judgements.
- When there is disillusionment with representative institutions, people prefer to make decisions for themselves, decisions made directly by the people may now carry more authority.
- Advantages of representative democracy: elected representatives may use superior knowledge and judgement. This avoids hasty and emotional decisions made directly by the people.
- Representatives and parties are able to mediate between the interests of different sections of society. Direct democracy means the will of the majority always prevails, making minorities very vulnerable.
- Issues which involve such conflicting interests require complex solutions. Direct democracy tends to reduce all questions to over-simplified answers.
1 of 2
- Demands made directly by the people are often incoherent and illogical. Representative democracy can make better sense of these demands and convert them into political programmes.
Is Britain a liberal democracy?
- A liberal democracy is where: - government is accountable to the people, there are free and fair elections, there is a peaceful, orderly transfer of power, losing parties accept the democratic legitimacy of winning parties.
- Information is freely available to the citizenry, the rights and liberties of citizens are taken into account and protected.
- The powers of government are controlled and limited by law or elected institutions or both.
- A variety of beliefs, opinions, cultures and lifestyles are tolerated provided they do not threaten the security of the state.
2 of 2