Family Diversity + life course
- Created by: Richard Dixon
- Created on: 08-05-13 17:47
Modernism + the nuclear family
Functionalist + New right are considered modernist.
> they see nuclear family as being best family type.
- Parsons > functional fit for family + society.
Nuclear family suits geographically mobile workforce and socialisation of children.
The new right
Firmly opposed to family diveristy / anti feminist.
Traditional nuclear family is correct family type.
- clear cut division of labour ( instrumental / expressive roles)
Family is natural + based on biology
social problems are caused by > family diversity + high crimes/ education failure.
X- lone parents unable to disapline children/ burden on welfare system.
X- no male role model > this increases delinquency + social stability.
- marriage is seen as essential basis for creating social stability.
Amato - children in lone parent families face greater risks of poverty, education failure, crime + health problems. >> as well as future family breakdown.
New right say return to traditional values will prevent damage to children.
- As conservatives, they are against taxation + government spending.
>> family breakdown has increased welfare spending. knock on effect on taxes.
>> High taxation + benifits are known as 'Perverse insentives'.
- punishing responsible behaviour + rewarding irresponsible.
Underlies traditional family - men dont work to support family.
They encourage dependancy culture.
Criticisms of the new right
Ann Oakley > the new right wrongly assume gender roles are due to biology. - cross cultural studies show otherwise.
Feminists >> nuclear family is favoured as it oppresses women and shows gender inequality.
> Keeps women financially dependant.
Chester : the Neo- conventional family
Robert Chester > important change from traditional nuclear ( conventional) family to 'neo-conventional' family.
Neo-conventional family is similar to symmetrical. - dual earners.
- Chester says nuclear family is part of a life cycle.
People may live in different types of family structure during different stages of life.
The Rapoports: Five types of family diversity
Family diversity represents freedom of choice. - acceptant of cultures.
1) Organisational diversity > conjugal roles / wage earners. who does what?
2) Cultural diversity> cutural, religions, ethnic groups have different structures.
3) social class diversity > income differences in household/ class differences in child rearing.
4) life stage diversity > structures acording to stage in the life cycle.
5) Generational diversity > older + younger attitudes + experiences/ eg views on divorce/ cohabitation.
Post modernity and the life course.
Post modernists say modernists ignore : individuals as social actors.
They say our actions are shaped by society.
Life course analysis
Tamara Hareven- Choices, timing, sequences of events are turning points.
- life course analysis focuses on meanings.
- she favours unstructed interviews.
- Two strengths - what individuals consider to be important / choices of individuals.
Pick and mix what type of structure at different times.
Giddins: choice + equality
- Equality of relationships has occured due to: contraception allowing sex and not reproduction/ women gaining independance.
'Pure Relationship' where tradition and laws dont affect how people act.
Trying different relationships defines who we are.
Beck - 'risk society' + the negotiated family.
Tradition has less influence and people have more choice.
- we make choices according to risk.
Although with traditional family it was unequal, it was stable and gave everyone roles.
- Gender equality undermines this (women expect equality)
- Greater indervidualism
This has led to a new family 'Negotiated family'
Although its more equal, it is less stable- People can leave when family doesnt satisfy their needs.
PIck and mix society - creates identy.
Electronic media has broken barriers of time + patterns.
This diversity + choice means modernists + functionalist cant generalise.
Stacey - the divorce- extended family
Stacey - says greater choice benifits women.
-> women can be free from oppression + shape family to meet their needs.
-Divorce extended family is one whereby divorce connects people rather than marriage.
Morgan -> its pointless making large scale generalisations of the family.
Weeks : the growing acceptance of diversity
- Long term attitude shift.
- sexual morality is personal choice.
But despite changes, patterns are still traditional.
For/ Against family diversity
For - Postmodernist/ feminists/ stacey/ weeks/ chester/ rapoports.
Against- functionalists/ parsons/ new right/ Amato
For/ Against family diversity
For - Postmodernist/ feminists/ stacey/ weeks/ chester/ rapoports.
Against- functionalists/ parsons/ new right/ Amato
Related discussions on The Student Room
- CRITICISMS OF THE MARXIST VIEW OF THE FAMILY - Help please. »
- sociology paper structure help »
- AQA A Level Sociology Paper 2 (7192/2) - 9th June [Exam Chat] »
- how far away should you move from your home to feel independent? »
- Sociology Help Thread »
- Is UCL full of rich kids? »
- Manchester or birmingham?? »
- Student loan calculation unfair? »
- Going to uni at 22 and graduating at 25! Worried about fashion degree course »
- At what age did you move out and live alone? »
Comments
No comments have yet been made