Families and Households - Couples
- Created by: malmond
- Created on: 23-05-19 12:01
What is the domestic division of labour?
The roles men and women play in relation to housework, paidwork and childcare
Parsons - functionalist perspective
Bevlieved in the tradtional nuclear family
Roles should be separate
Husband = breadwinner - earns the money = instrumental role
Wife = socialises and cares for childs emotional and physical needs = expressive role
They believe that this is the best way for a smooth functioning society
Bott
Believed that many couples still have segregated roles
However..... she believes things were changing slowly because of more joint conjugal roles
e.g couples sharing domestic tasks, childcare and leisure time
Willmott and Young
Gradually overtime roles have shifted from separated to joint
Tasks although are not the same, are equally shared
This means that the family becomes more balanced
= The March of Progress (steady change)
Oakley
Disagrees with Willmott and Young
She argues that men and women roles are still segregated
Women - Often does paid work AND do most of the domestic tasks and childcare
=DUAL BURDEN
She also found that only 15% of husbands had a high level of participation in housework
Crompton and Lyonette
Why is there still a gendered division of labour?
Cultural or ideological explanation
Because of patirarchal norms and values and how we are socialised
Material or economic explanation
Statistically women earn less than men, meaning it makes sense for women to do more unpaid work
Gershuny
Couples whose parents had an equal relatinship, are more likely to share housework
Arber and Ginn
Better paid middle class women were able to buy commercially produced products and services
e.g labour saving devices - dishwasher
e.g childcare
Duncomb and Marsden
Women have to perform a triple shift
1) Housework
2) Paid work
3) Emotion work
Willmott and Young
Rise of the symmetrical nuclear family because of major social changes
Such as changes in women's position (1970 equal pay act)
New technology
How the roles of women have changed since the 70s?
They can now file for a divorce
**** in marriage became illegal
Contraception - can plan their furture
More of a social life - due to labour saving devices
Rise of feminism
(Links to Sue Sharpe)
Resources and Decision making in Households
Kempson
In low income families, women put family before themself to make ends meet etc.
For example, they may not go out ith friends to save money
Edgell
Very important decisions (such as moving house)are made either by the man alone or together
Pahl and Vogler
2 systems of money management
1) The allowance system
Husband gives wife an allowance so she can budget but still meet needs
2) Pooling
Both partners have access to income - joint accounts etc
Smart
Most gay men and lesbians attached no importance to who controlled the money
Domestic Violence
Issues with DV statistics
Repoting
Stigma
They may not see it s a crime
May not want to get the abuser in trouble
Recording - police may be relucatnt to record because theres a lot of paper work
Radical Feminist Explanation
It occurs because of patriarchal culture and ideology
Men hold the power - use violence as a form of soical control
Eval
Women commit DV too!
The Materialist Explanation
It's about social and economic inequaility
For example
low income
stress
poor housing
Eval
What about wealthy people?
Dobash and Dobash
Feminist approach
Marriage legitimates Domestic Violence - conferring power and authority on husbands
Radical Feminist Explanation cont.
Millett and Firestone
All societies/institutions have been founded on patriarchy
e.g
male domination in state institutions
Eval
Fail to explain which type of women are most at risk of DV
Materialist Feminist Explanations cont.
Wilkinson and Pickett
DV is a result of stress on family members caused by social inequality
David Cheal
Police and other state agencies arent prepared to become involved in the family because:
Private sphere
Family is a good thing - tend to neglect the 'darker side'
Indivduals are free agents - women CAN leave abusive relationships
Why don't DV victims leave the relationship?
Emotional reasons
Believe that th abuser will change
Fear of the abser finding out they have reported them
Attachment
Situational reasons
Economic dependence on th abuser
Fear of physical harm
Worry of emotional damage to children
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Student loan calculation unfair? »
- sociology paper structure help »
- My experience with Student Finance England living away from parents in Scotland »
- Loans wont cover living »
- The social unit that lives in a house is known as a household. Most commonly, a hous »
- how far away should you move from your home to feel independent? »
- Student Maintenance loan question »
- Low Maximum Maintenance Loan »
- Guardian - UK middle classes ‘struggling despite incomes of up to £60,000 a year’ »
- Scholarships for low income families »
Comments
No comments have yet been made