educational attainment and ethnicity
- Created by: lxigh
- Created on: 27-03-19 19:50
ethnicity
- Britain is a multicultural society - long history of immigration of minority ethnic groups
theoretical explanations
- functionalism - see some ethnic minorities as predisposed to fail in school and look for cultural/genetic explanations
- marxism - overlook in favour of class
- interactionism - see labelling, teachers, and institutionalised racism as being the causes of educational underattainment
- feminism - girls from the ethnic minorities experience a double disadvantage - sexism and racism
- new right - agree with functionalism, but are very concerned with the percieved failure of boys, claiming that west Indian boys in particular lack suitable role models because single parenthood is more common
genetic theories
- little/no evidence even though it has been proposed by New Right thinkers such as Murray, Herrnstein, Eyesnck, and others - the basis is that intelligence tests are a valid measure of ability
- Black African children tend to over-achieve compared to white children, while Black Caribbean pupils tend to under-achieve
poverty and class
- Strand (1999) - in primary and secondary schools in London, both black and white able children from disadvantaged backgrounds failed to make the expected progress - however, Chinese and Indian heritage pupils tended to do better than predicted
- suggestions include the fact that ethnic minority children tend to attend low-performing schools, have low expectations placed upon them by teachers, and are percieved as having problem behaviour
- however the worst performing ethnic groups are white travellers and white w/c British pupils - this suggests that although racism is significant, it does not explain why pupils from some ethnic backgrounds underachieve
english as an additional language
- government data suggests that approximately 10% of children in English schools have English as an additional language (EAL), and use different languages in their home
- over 90% of Bangladeshi children qualify as EAL, whereas only 7% of Black Caribbean pupils use a different language in their home than in their school
- 31% of EAL children are from low income families whereas only 15% of non-EAL qualify for free school meals
- EAL pupils are often at low starting points in infant school, but appear to make greater progress as they catch up with the language through school
cultural differences
- Gypsy/Roma or Traveller children show that culture may impact on educational achievement - they tend to be from the most disadvantaged families - far more attend primary school than secondary school, suggesting that many families don't register their children as school
- Chinese children are consistently among the high attainers - it is thought that Chinese parents strongly encourage/demand high performance -- at GCSE, Chinese FSM students perform above the national average for all pupils
- Chua - Chinese parents are 'tiger parents' - they cannot accept failure
racism
- The Swan Report (1985) - schools should promote the idea of multicultural Britain because many of them are institutionally racist
- Gilroy, Sewess, Modood, and Safia Mirza - pointed to racist attitudes among schools and teachers
- Wright (1992) - although they oppose racist views, teachers often have stereotypical attitudes - some children are seen as problematic, Asian girls are seen as submissive and are overlooked, Black Caribbean boys are seen as having low academic ability -- leads to poor behaviour
- Childline (2013) - 1'400 cildren reported incidents of racism in schools, evidence that young Muslims are being called offensive names linked to terrorism and Islamophobia - an increase from 802 in 2012, although tere is no way to be sure if there is more bullying or whether more people are reporting incidents
- Hall - racism in schools led to the rejection of schooling by Black Caribbean boys - the 'culture of resistance'
ethnocentric curriculum
- one's own culture is central to an understnading of the world
- the national curriculum over looks the contribution of non-while people to British history, Black people are usually only considered in a negative view or in steroetypes, such as slavery
- non-whites are frequently overlooked, which damages the self esteem of non-white children in schools
single parenthood and the new right
- African Caribbean communities tend to have relatively high levels of lone parenthood - financial challenge is a known factor of low school attainment
- the New Right are very critical of single motherhood - it contributes to huge social problems among te poor
- Wright and others - single mothers can be positive role models for young girls - this may account for the relatively high rates of achievement for Black Caribbean girls compared to Black Caribbean boys
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Help with History Nea Coursework »
- AQA A Level Sociology Paper 1 (7192/1) - 22nd May [Exam Chat] »
- Sociology AQA ALevel »
- Spss question »
- OCR A-level Sociology Paper 3 (H580/03) - 14th June 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- UCAS parents education »
- PGDE History 2024 »
- Does college affect Uni? »
- AQA a level sociology Paper 1 »
- AQA Sociology - Education Paper 1 »
Comments
No comments have yet been made