The threat must be of death or serious injury. However cumulative threats may be considered if they are serious
Valderama-vega: imported cocaine due to threat from mafia, individual threats not enough but together added to death
threat doesnt need to be aimed at the victim- Conway: threat made at passenger in the car
Graham: set out a 2 part test for duress:
subjective- was d compelled to act as he did becuase he reasonably believed he had to due to fear of death or serious injury. HANSAN made this stricter- must be a genuine and resonable beliefe
Objective- if so would the sober person of reasonable firmness sharing D's characteristics have acted in the same way
Can only use duress if there was no safe avenue of escape- Gill didnt take the safe avenue
Comments
No comments have yet been made