Dissolution of the Monastaries 1535-1541

  • Fall of Anne Boleyn
  • Motives behind the dissolution
  • Reactions against the Dissolutions
  • Consequences of the dissolutions
  • Created by: samantha
  • Created on: 21-03-12 15:08

Fall of Anne Boleyn


  • Many believed she was a witch
  • Henry viewed Anne as an 'evil omen'
  • accused of:
    • engaging in elicit sexual acts whith 5 other men including her own brother
    • afflicting Henry with impotence
    • conspired to kill both Mary Tudor and Henry FitzRoy
  • had a deformed baby --> said to be result of gross sexual conduct
  • sources claim candidates chosen to be accused of adultery alongside Anne were 'Libertines' = a faction henry very much disliked
1 of 22

Fall of Anne Boleyn (2)


  • Anne = carefully plotted against
  • Jane Seymour deliberately teased the king --> poisoned his mind against Anne; Married just ten days after Ann'es execution
  • Jane kept the king occupied whilst Cromwell provided the evidence against anne


  • Countess of Worcester was pregnant with illegitimate child --> brother infuriated = stated 'Anne is worse'; brother then tells 2 friendsFitzWilliam and Cromwell who then told the King
2 of 22

Outline of Motives

MONASTARIES = generic term used to describe a place where you would find an order of monks/nuns i.e convents, friary etc.


  • Financial --> said to be the main factor influencing the kings decision
  • Religious --> said to be the least important influencing the king
  • Political
  • Personal

* all factors are interlinked

* In theory if this went well Henry would never need to go to parliament for taxes ever again. The more money he had, the more power he gained

3 of 22

Financial Motives (1)


  • 1530'S --> crown = poor; spent money on wars with france
  • Monarch was expected to live of his own --> inflation affected revenue
  • Act for first fruits and tenths (1534) brought Henry £4000
      • made up of revenue from bishoprics and forcing clergy to pay one tenth of their income to the crown on an annual basis
  • 1534 idea of taking church land had already been thought of and abandoned
  • Cromwell suggested evaluatiion of the church so Henry could tax them realistically
  • put together the document of 'valor Ecclesiastiais' listing all property owned by the church in England
  • showed annual income approx £136,00
  • could make significant differences in increasing his prestige especially amongst other european monarch i.e Francis I
4 of 22

Finanial Motives (2)


  • Henry saw no conflict between the break with Rome and remaining a catholic
  • Henry retained antipapalist views in order to increase his power as monarch
  • henry overestimated the threat from abroad
    • no doubt Pope would ask Charles V and Francis I to mount a military campaign against England
    • attack delayed due to continuation of disputes between Habsburgs and Valois
  • Henry had the threat of excommunication and a country could be lay under interdict = no burias, mass, christenings --> ordinaries may disobey king
  • Money aqquired from an attack on religious houses could be used to construct necessary defences from crusades
  • Whilst being militarily weak, Henry was keen to maintain the state of isolated neutrality from what was happening in main land Europe
  • Henry's ambitions were to attack, France, regaining his claim to the territory --> money gained from monastaries could be used for war with fr.
  • Henry was commited to the idea that a monarch proved his worth on the battlefield
5 of 22

Religious Motives


  • attack on monastaries = attack on good works as a means of salvation
  • catholics believed they were douing good by giving to the church
  • injunctions drawn up by Cromwell in Henry's name (1536) intended  to remove all superstition forbidding monks to worship icons
  • strict instructions given against pilgrimages and praying to saints
  • people should not offer candles/money to images/relics of saints; only God emphasising restoration of healthand grant forgiveness (idoltary)
  • 1538 Becketts shrine destroyed by order of government = pilgrim centre
  • attack on monastaries = attack on nuns/ monks standards
  • Eton: by 16th cent. lay people had no respect for monks because of poor behaviour/ disrespect for vows
    • evidence = provided by those who conducted visitations i.e Layton/ Tregonwell suggested those who lived in religious houses were greedy / lazy/ sexualised
  • Recent historians challenge this : inspections = too short, evidence fabricated, nuns could have had children before they took their vows, retiring to a nunnery to escape marriage
6 of 22

Political Motives

  • large % of house of lords belonged to the the church
    • made up of nobles, bishops and abbots
  • disolving the monastaries = need to break with rome
  • dissolving monastaries would reduce the religious influence withing the House of lords as more power was handed over to the nobles
  • Henry forced people in monastaries to swear oath whereby they recognised him as supreme head of the church in England rather than the Pope
  • Monastaries had HQ's in foreign countries and had strong ties with the pope
    • taking orders from foreign power = potential riva
7 of 22

Personal Motives

  • from Henrys point of view, family and securing the Rudor dynasty was the most important
  • needed nobility to accept whoever he left to succeed him
  • Henry closed monastaries henry would have patronage  he could then give to people to gain their support
  • nobles preffered Henry as the head of the church --> did not like the wealth of the monastaries
  • People were keen to get their hands on church property
  • Cromwell  was trying to keep some of this land for the crown but it was impossible to take care of it all
  • Nobility & Gentry saw profit in this
8 of 22

Roland Blyton

  • Abbot of Rievaulx
  • Cisterian monk --> focussed on primative monasticism
  • intended to uphold rules of St Bernaduct;emphasis on manual work, prayer and praise
  • elected to abbacy for Rievaulx in 1533
  • former abbot = investigated by Royal Commisionerson allegations of misconduct --> resigned
  • benefited from relaxations
  • enjoyed aristrocratic lifestyle
  • retired to land previously owned by abbey
  • recieved handsome pension
9 of 22

Enforcement of Dissolutions

  • dissolutions led to the appointment of Cromwell as Vicegerant to the King
    • responsible for control of the church
  • introduced programme of visitations of monastaries in 153
    • similar to checking religious houses under church
    • follwed by 'Valor Ecclesiastias which listed all property owned by church
  • Marcch 1536 = act passed by parliament for dissolution of the smaller monastaries
  • 300 religious houses = deemed to have income less than £2000 per year
  • 1536 at not preseted as an attack on monastaries as members of religious houses to be disolved were offered oppurtunity to transfer
  • act gave king right to exept those he deemed fit 
    • 67/300 exempted --> probably through bribe
  • was important to stop monastaries movable wealth out of the country
  • commissioners actedd quickly --> Innates expelled and goods siezed to the tower of london
10 of 22

Enforcement of Dissolutions (2)

  • led to uprisings i.e lancashire and pilgrimage of grace
    • Cromwell & Henry reluctant to take further actions
  • demand for restoration lead to henry restoring a select few
  • once suh uprisings were defeated they were punished sufficiently
  • abbots of houses involved declared to be traitors
    • acts of attainder brought in
    • could be executed and property confiscated
  • 1540 all monastaries dissolved
  • final assault achieved through combination of persuasion, bribery, bullying and an act of parliament
    • 1539= act of parliament legalised voluntary surrender
    • not all surrendered--> accused of treason
    • 4 years = 800 religious houses closed
    • lay brothers forced to find work
    • nuns thrown back to family
11 of 22

Role of Cromwell

  • behind wanting to make Henry ' a man of his own'
  • servant of Henry VIII --> power limited as he had to follow kings orders
  • seemed to follow Wolseys footsteps --> limited comparisons
    • Wolsey dissolved 29 small monastaries, set up educational institutions
  • Cromwell closed monastaries for 3 main reasons:
    • raise money for the king
    • gain support from the nobility
    • destroy the supersticious approach to religion and unnaceptable practices
  • skilled administator, organising church and break with rome
  • very much in charge of dissolutions --> planned in advance/ ad hoc
  • Cromwell was testing for an attack then larger dissolutions would take place
  • court of augmentations set up to deal with property matters
  • saw to it justices of peace kept him informed of dissidents
    • 65 executed for opposing change
  • dissolutions = irrevocable --> nothing more than a political move to gain money for attacks on france
12 of 22

Lincolnshire Rising 1536

  • Act of dissolutions required commisioners to inspect monastaries
  • caused problems as they were challenging institutions which valued for religious/socioeconomic roles
  • Niholas Metton led the uprising encouraged core of 20+  in order to sieze the rep of the Bishop of Lincoln and royal commisioners in the area
  • reported crowd of 3000 advanced from Louth
  • gathered support from Horncastle --> 10000 marched to lincoln
  • 4th oct = attacked leading official & murdered him
  • symbolic = divided clothes amongst crowd
  • rebellion regarded as treasonable --> Royal army dispatched
  • Gentry decided to sue for pardonand encouraged people to dispense
  • great reluctance to follow this advice and serious unrest for 12 days
  • Some of those involved placed banner showing 5 wounds of christ
  • different groups had different motives
    • ordinaries : afraid crown would take the treasures of churches, worried about jos and land rentals
    • gentry : predominantly politial and religious concerns
13 of 22

Pilgrimage Of Grace 1536

  • Led by Robert Aske = lawyer , capable of compromise
  • grew in pockets with 4 main captains = Charity, Poverty, Faith & Pity
  • peacefully sieged castles i.e Lord Darcy ceded Pontefract castle
  • had majority of north under control = 30,000 rebels
  • did not criticise the king
  • governnment underestimated the scale of uprising
  • Duke of Norfolk sent to negotiate with rebels --> agreement was clear
  • Norfolk played for time = persuaded Henry of the rightness of the demands
  • 6th december = bargain struck at doncaster whilst parliament to discuss demands
  • agreed whilst parliament met abbeys would continue to stand, dissolutions suspended
  • Aske convinced rebels of the sincerity of promises
  • Aske had been invited to court to discuss petition further
  • pilgrims could return home confident concerns will be dealt with
14 of 22

Motives of Pilgrimage of Grace - Religious

  • people are still deeply upset by the break with rome
  • both rebellions were the result of recent changes to religion
  • wanted rid of protestant reformers i.e Boleyn, Cranmer etc
  • wanted monastaries restored
  • evidence of motives found in use of religious symbolism
  • Aske suggested economic importance of abbeys
  • tried to use things which would work against Henry
  • important part of popular culture i.e praying for the dead
15 of 22

Motves for Pilgrimage of Grace - Political

  • against the actions of Henrys advisors
    • responsible for the break with rome, dissolutions and legislation
  • 1536 = some historans believed the aragonese faction were behind this i.e against divorce
  • focussed on low politics represeted by yeomen an high politics of nobility/court
  • duty of nobility was to advise king when they felt he had made any bad decisions from bad advice and prevent commoners uprising
  • 1536 = supporters of the king might wish to portray the yeoman as having beliefs of the country --> see themselves as caring and honest government with clear sense of right/wrong
  • nobility/gentry and yeomen would argue that they were acting in the kings interest
  • gentry and nobility stated when the commoners rose spontaneously that it was they who took control of the situation
16 of 22

Henry's Actions in Ending the Uprising

  • despite promises made, nothing happened
    • Henry had no intention on fulfilling wishes
    • came to realise they had been fooled
  • considerable discussion over how far royal supremacy had been established
  • new leader emerged = Bigod
    • decided to seize scarborough --> only beverly held for a short period of time
    • fled to cumberland = captured
  • small no. of incidents of unrest were reported across yorkshire
  • 16th feb = mustering of the commons in eskdale but gentry turned on them
  • Henry persued systematic policy of punishmentand sent Norfolk north
  • 144 executions took place including Aske, Bigod, Husse, Darcy
  • no. of vicious reprisals i.e burninng wives at stake of gentry on fringe of the rebellion
  • clearest evidence of Henry's fear for his government was the execution of Thomas Miller who was instrumental in securing negotiations with pilgrims in doncaster
17 of 22

Outcomes of the Pilgrimage

  • Henry made no. of leaders of Pilgrimages such as Baves and Elleker parts of the council in the north
  • promise to restore monastaries ignored and failed
  • Hery excommunicated by pope
  • 6 articles was published = clear henry saw the country as catholic
  • statute of wills passed in 1540 more firmly recognised rights of landowners to dispute property
  • 1540 = Cromwell removed from power
  • 1543 = Mary restored to 2nd in place for succession
18 of 22

Implications of Dissolutions on Society

  • abbeys of England & Wales amongst greatest land owners and institutions
  • sources of charity and medical care = hospitals lost
  • vagrancy and sturdy beggars became a cause for concern
  • limited sources of relief foor poor
  • partial sollution later established through elizabetgab poor law
  • eve of reformation = monastaries owned 2,000,000 acres of land
  • transfer of power for those who purchased property  --> owned by king
  • passed on to nobility/gentry established families allowed them rights to their land
  • brought end to masses said for souls and making children monks/nuns
19 of 22

Impacts on Culture

  • loss of monastary libraries i.e worcester priory had 600 books - only 6 survived
    • some books destroyed for precious binding, others sold/burned
  • books were irreplacable
    • many of the anglo saxons manuscripts were lost
  • precious possesions taken away and sold by court of augmentations
  • Henry did invest some wealth into education
    • grammar schools set up in canterbury
    • universities/colleges rebranded
  • Sinods may not have happened as a result of monastaries being dissolved
20 of 22

Impacts of the Pilgrimage on the Church

  • dissolution of the monastaries represented final break from formal links with the continental religion and catholic church
  • 8000 extra priests = addressed issues of illiterate clergy
  • reorganisation of the church
  • 1540 = 6 new bishoprics created i.e oxford
    • lead to changes in parliament
    • good because some bishoprics had became too big
  • Bishops = handpicked, supported by king = more support in the house of lords
21 of 22

Motives for Pilgrimage of Grace - Socioeconomic

  • Economic problems = serious as they made life harder
  • enclosure land = reason to take action --> land owner would fence off common land which means they had no access to wood or space to graze their annimals leading to hardship
  • evidence found when enclosure ocured in settle in 1535 it appeared in the articles for rebels demands
  • those who rented land found rent increasing
  • Henry wanted to retrieve land --> feudal system = land owners not happy
  • Henry wanted Gentry to pay inheritance to get land
22 of 22


No comments have yet been made

Similar History resources:

See all History resources »See all British monarchy - Tudors and Stuarts resources »