1) Pontizovsky 2006 - Short term
D> Looked at agreement on diagnosis of type of depression on admission and a year later on release in Islamic psychiatric hospitals in 2003.
F> There was an 83 PPV rate (83% stayed them same.) Therefore 2/10 diagnoses changed.
S> Low reliability in short term diagnosis
E> -Problem could have actually changed
-High ecological validity- natural observation.
2) Baca-Garcia 2007 - Long term
D> Looked at 2322 patients assessed at a spanish psychiatric hospital between 1992-2004. Each patient was assessed atleast 10 times.
F> 54 PPV (54% stayed the same)
S> Even lower rates of reliability over long term assessments.
E> Large sample size and meta-analysis, so generalisable.
Comments
No comments have yet been made