Criticisms
1. Problems with the definition of God
2. Existence is not a predicate/perfection
3. Defining things into existence
Problems with the definition of God
All Ontological arguments move from the definition to existence.
Anselm's definition = That than which nothing greater can be thought
Descartes' definition = The supremely perfect being
Both suggested once we understand the definition we must understand this entails existence
This is where Aquinas starts off.
Criticism 1
We don't all share the definition of God
Response: It doesn't matter
Comments
No comments have yet been made