Pages in this set

Page 1

Preview of page 1
CRITICAL THINKING REVISION
Unit F503: Ethical Reasoning and Decision-making
Assessment by Specification

Candidates should be able to....
Evaluate a range of source
material and select appropriate
ideas, comments and information
to support their reasoning and
analysis of complex moral and
ethical problems.
Identify and evaluate conflicting
ideas and arguments within…

Page 2

Preview of page 2
problems.
Demonstrate understanding of the
nature of a dilemma.
3.3.2 In response to real issues,
construct their own arguments.

Page 3

Preview of page 3
Questions 1 and 2 Possible Questions
Suggest and briefly explain two weaknesses in using document 1 as evidence / to
support / to inform ... (6 marks)
2 marks: Clear explanation of a significant and specific weakness.
1 mark: For relevant reference to the documents.

FOREST has a vested interest…

Page 4

Preview of page 4
· Document 1 begs the question when stating that investigators "cross-check the bank accounts
of benefit thieves". Presumably the checking is to discover whether they are benefit thieves or
not.
· It is unclear from whom benefit thieves are stealing. Document 1 accuses them of stealing
from "law-abiding taxpayers" and…

Page 5

Preview of page 5
The fact that Denise van Outen "blamed" her use of sunbeds for causing pigmentation scars
does not prove that it caused them. Other things could have caused her scars. (Causation)


The teachers who left were not necessarily "the weakest teachers", just ones who opposed
the monitoring. [must relate to the…

Page 6

Preview of page 6
Suggest and briefly explain one problem in using the evidence in
paragraph X of Document X to support / oppose ...
FOREST has a vested interest to oppose the proposed policy, because its purpose is "to
champion the rights of smokers", so it cannot be expected to present a fair…

Page 7

Preview of page 7
The evidence in para 2 from "countries where IVF is regularly given to women in their fifties"
is biased, since if medical opinion was against it, presumably it would not be regularly given.
As "Medical Director" of an "independent fertility clinic", the author has a vested interest to
select evidence…

Page 8

Preview of page 8
Suggest three alternative choices that ... could make. (6 marks)
For each of three answers:
2 marks Clear statement of possible decision.
1 mark Vague statement of possible decision.

Examples of 2-mark answers:

Include smoking as one factor ­ but not a decisive factor ­ in assessing the overall suitability…

Page 9

Preview of page 9
Women over the age limit may succeed in misrepresenting their age by borrowing a birth
certificate from a younger friend or relative.

Unless the limit is imposed internationally, women over the age limit may evade the
restriction by travelling abroad for treatment.

It would be hard to set the age…

Page 10

Preview of page 10
Suggest and briefly explain two ways in which the data in Document X might or
might (not) be useful in deciding ...
For each of two answers:
3 marks: Valid point clearly identified and clearly explained.
Because the survey is based on self-reporting, the numbers of offences may be understated,…

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Critical Thinking resources:

See all Critical Thinking resources »See all resources »