A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies, Ontological Argument

An overview of the ontological argument, again using the Reid and Tyler "A2 Religious Studies" book, wellington college powerpoint and a couple of bits from notes I found on here but can't remember who by- sorry!

HideShow resource information
  • Created by: Courtney
  • Created on: 28-05-12 16:28

Pages in this set

Page 1

Preview of page 1
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.


Ontological Argument
What type of Argument is it?
The argument is "A Priori"- means it is not based on experience of the world,
but comes to a conclusion that is logically necessary. It is deductive,
meaning if the premises are accepted, they logically entail the necessity…

Page 2

Preview of page 2
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.


In Proslogion 3 the second form of Ontological argument was proposed-

1) Something that cannot not exist (necessary existence) is greater than
something which could not exist (contingent existence).
2) If `That than which no greater can be conceived', could be thought to not
exist, this…

Page 3

Preview of page 3
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.




Gaunilo REJECTS Anselm's argument;
Gaunilo himself believed in God- he just
thought that Anselm's arguments were a
bit rubbish.

He used Anselm's logic in relation to an
Island....

Think of an Island. White sand...clear seas...
Just because you think of this Island does it
exist?

Gaunilo…

Page 4

Preview of page 4
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.


Uh ohhhhhh. Anselm's back!

A Different Ontological Argument- Descartes;
Descartes and the perfect being;
Like Anselm, Descartes wanted to should that when we use the word `God',
we are talking of a supremely perfect being, and anything perfect by definition
must exist, so his argument is…

Page 5

Preview of page 5
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.


Hmmm. ..that's right.

A triangle has 3 sides, and angles equal two right-angles..

God is perfect, and must exist.... Obviously.




Objection's to the Ontological Arguments;
Kant...
1) Disputed one of the most fundamental
parts of Descartes' and Anselm's
arguments. The idea of existence as a
predicate-…

Page 6

Preview of page 6
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.


3) The greater the limitations of this creator, the more impressive
the achievement.
4) The greatest limitation possible is non-existence.
5) Therefore, a world created by a non-existent creator would be
greater than a world created by an existent creator.
6) An existing God is therefore…

Page 7

Preview of page 7
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.


Malcolm; The statement `God Necessarily Exists' can either be impossible,
possible or necessary. The existence is only impossible if it contains a logical
contradiction. So a four sided triangle is impossible. But `God necessarily exists'
doesn't contain a contradiction. So we can rule impossibility of existing…

Page 8

Preview of page 8
A2 EDEXCEL Religious Studies.

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Religious Studies resources:

See all Religious Studies resources »