Functionalist VS marxist views

HideShow resource information

Functionalist VS marxist views

Similarities

  • FUNCTIONALIST THEORY: Consensus theory. Organic analogy - functionalists see the family as a vital organ in maintaining the body of society.
  • MURDOCK - argues there are 4 main functions of the family:
  • Sexual - expressing sexuality in a socially acceptable/ approved context
  • Reproduction - the family reproduces and rears children
  • Socialisation - family is very important in the primary socialisation of children and teaches children shared ideas and beliefs (value consensus) which functionalists believe is important to maintain a stable society
  • Economic - the family provides food and shelter for its members
  • PARSONS - two basic and irreducible functions of the family : the primary socialisation of children and the stabilisation of adult personalities
  • Primary socialisation of children - teaching children the norms and values of their society and teach them their families culture
  • The stabilisation of adult personalities - in industrial societies, the pressure of work and the struggles of working life threatens to destabilise personalities - wife's expressive role relieves the tension by providing love and understanding

Differences

  • MARXIST THEORY
  • Do not regard the nuclear family as a necessity
  • Conflict theory
  • See the family within the framework of a capitalist society  which is based on private property, driven by profit and is riddled with conflict between social classes.
  • ENGLES - believed the monogamous nuclear family developed when ownership of private property arised so men needed to know who their children were in order to pass their possessions on.
  • ALTHUSSER - argued that in order for capitalism to survive, the working class (prolateriat) must submit to the ruling class (bourgeoisie)

Overall comparison

FUNCTIONALISM - criticised for downplaying conflict - present nuclear families as harmonious which ignores the dark side of the family. Parsons view of the instrumental and expressive role of men and women is very old fashioned - not the case todayIt ignores the exploitation of women and ignores the harmful effects of the family (Leach)MARXISM - old fashioned - the idea that men marry to pass down their property ignores other reasons for getting married.Women are far less likely to marry for economic support  

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Sociology resources:

See all Sociology resources »See all Families and households resources »