AQA anthology poems : Relationship cluster

  • 2 votes

I'm finding it hard to choose 2 poems to compare with eachother, does anyone know any good pairs of poems .e.g. nettles and praise song for my mother because they both have nature and family in it ?? :) Thanks

Posted Fri 3rd June, 2011 @ 16:55 by Sara

14 Answers

  • 7 votes

Urm I personally would compare it to quickdraw

  1. Desperation = Q  = desperate for partner to stop hurtin her. G = despearte for partner to love her
  2. Cracks in relationship/ no improvements = Q = struture as if in a jigsaw (do you get what I mean?). G = 2 pairs of lines = partners stuck together, cant get out of relationship, not going anywhere
  3. Pain of loving someone = Q = 'pellets, bullets, gun, blast etc'. G = 'venemous, serpent, spell' = evil/ violent words  = bad experience in love
  4. Lack of stability = G = 'If' = so many possibilites. Q = landline phone/ mobile phone' = landline is a stable phone, doesnt move, she relises on objects for stability, not on her partner.

Hope this helped and good luck! :)

Answered Tue 7th June, 2011 @ 18:09 by Sara
  • 3 votes

Personally with nettles i would compare and contrast it with Sister Maude because both poems show family relationships and violence between the couple. Also Nettles could be compared with Hour because it shows both innocence and deception within a relationship. Meanwhile Brothers would also be a good choice as it shows the innocence between the youngest and the breakdown between a relationship

Meanwhile Born Yesterday could simply be compared with Brothers, Nettles & Harmonium since they show family relationships.

I Hope this could help !

Answered Mon 6th June, 2011 @ 20:31 by Reyez
  • 3 votes

I'm going to compare nettles to manhunt, because they both reflect the ideas of war and both use metaphors and personification etc. They also highlight the idea of pain and suffering, and the wife in Manhunt and the father in Nettles both try to ease pain. 
I also might compare nettles to harmonium because they are both based on family relationships and more specifically between father and son. They also reflect on the theme of memory and ideas of regret, suffering and the inevitablity of death
hope that helped :)

Answered Thu 26th January, 2012 @ 20:59 by Terrie
  • 2 votes

Might be a bit late now but for anyone doing the exam this year onwards, BBC bitesize has pages on each of the poems. One of the pages in the section is about poems that you could compare it to and why. They also have practise quastions for sopme of them about comparing the poems.

Answered Sun 22nd April, 2012 @ 21:59 by Anna G
  • 1 vote

Urm, those poems arent actually in the relationship cluster. The poems in the relationship cluster are

  1. quickdraw
  2. manhunt
  3. ghazal
  4. praise song for my mother
  5. nettles
  6. the famers bride
  7. sister maude
  8. brothers
  9. in paris with you
  10. to his coy mistress
  11. sonnet 43
  12. sonnet 116
  13. hour
  14. harmonium
  15. born yesterday

i'm finding it difficult to find a poem to compare nettles with and born yesterday :/

Answered Sat 4th June, 2011 @ 12:18 by Sara
  • 1 vote

i compare brothers with nettles , because of the family relationships , you could compaare nettles with harmonium because it nettles it is the father talking about his son and in harmonium its the son - simon armitage taking about his father , i love the quote "i being me and he being him " 

Answered Mon 30th April, 2012 @ 17:32 by Connah Greenhalgh - Team GR
  • 0 votes

Ahh sorry wrong book  x

Answered Sun 5th June, 2011 @ 15:10 by Lottie
  • 0 votes

Lol, thats allright, but thanks anyway for trying :) !!

Answered Sun 5th June, 2011 @ 17:04 by Sara
  • 0 votes

it really depends on the question you are answering because if it is about feelings then it would be different to structure of the poem

Answered Tue 7th June, 2011 @ 15:56 by Emmille
  • 0 votes

Oh no, english literature exam TOMORROW!!! What can i compare the poem ghazal to?

Answered Tue 7th June, 2011 @ 16:35 by blah
  • 0 votes

Do we have to learn every single poem in this cluster??!!!!!!!!!

Answered Wed 28th March, 2012 @ 12:17 by LippytheGreat
  • 0 votes

what could you compare these poems to and why?:

the manhunt

hour

quickdraw

ghazal

sonnet 116

sonnet 43

thankyouu so much! hate english lit =[[

xo

Answered Sat 5th May, 2012 @ 17:37 by Ekta Sharma
  • 0 votes

You could compare a poem to any other one in the relationships anthology, this is because it is more interesting to see the differences not the similarities. Obviously you have to state some of the similarities but try not to only talk about the similarities if you want a good grade.

Hope this helps and good luck :)

Answered Tue 8th May, 2012 @ 19:30 by Georgia
  • -3 votes

Search for my tongue by Sujata Bhatt and Presents from my aunts in pakistan by Moniza Alvi they are both about culture and how they find it hard to relate and fit in with both the world they are living in and the heritage they left behind. They are in the AQA Anthology book and are good poems to compare; I have done them myself and have many interesting devices to look at and the structures are cleverly portrayed, hope this helps :)

Answered Sat 4th June, 2011 @ 11:48 by Lottie