tb4 revision
- Created by: rubybarber1408
- Created on: 06-07-20 13:34
View mindmap
- Roman Catholic- Eucharist
- TRANSUBSTANSIATION
- beloved by Roman Catholic + Eastern Orthodox
- the change in the ESSENCE of the bread and wine
- substance stays same but essence changes
- when essence changes the bread and wine IS transubstantiates into the body and blood of Jesus
- substance stays same but essence changes
- aquinas took from the teaching of plato +aristotle who taught about matter and form
- Aquinas took this and said 'every object is matter and form, but used the language substance and essence
- matter +form= substance + essence
- Aquinas took this and said 'every object is matter and form, but used the language substance and essence
- TRANSIGNIFICATION
- EdwardSchillbeeckx
- 1914-2009
- says consecrated/blessed bread and wine takes on the real significance of christ, but are not chemically changed
- Christ is not physically present
- it is what the person perceives as they take the bread and wine
- they perceive that they are taking the body +blood
- the bread and wine become a sign that points the person to Jesus
- they perceive that they are taking the body +blood
- EdwardSchillbeeckx
- TRANSFINALISATION
- Karl Rainer
- 1904-1984
- The belief that the bread and wine do not physically changeout the PURPOSE of the bread changes
- if you take bread into a poorer community, the breads purpose is to feed physical hunger.
- if you take bread into the church, the purpose of the bread is to spiritually nourishChristians.
- if you take bread into a poorer community, the breads purpose is to feed physical hunger.
- Karl Rainer
- Catholic Church disagreed with tranignification and transfinalization
- 'The spread of these and similar opinions does great harm to belief in and devotion to the eucharist'
- TRANSUBSTANSIATION
Comments
No comments have yet been made