Substance Dualism
- Created by: Freyae99
- Created on: 03-01-18 20:31
View mindmap
- Substance Dualism
- Key terms
- Substance: something that doesn't depend on anything else to exist. it possess properties and persists through change.
- Property: they cannot exist on their own - they depend on substance to exist; they can change even when the substance persists.
- Mental properties include mental states such as belief and mental events such as pain.
- Physical properties are properties of objects that can be investigated by the natural sciences.
- Ontologically distinct: things that exist separately from each other e.g. the mind and body.
- Descartes Conceivability
- The mind is something that thinks and the body is something that is extended.
- P1. It is conceivable that the mind can exist without the body.
- IC1. Therefore it is possible that the mind and body are distinct substances.
- C. Therefore the mind and body are distinct substances.
- IC1. Therefore it is possible that the mind and body are distinct substances.
- In this, our clear and distinct ideas of the mind and body must be complete and exclusive.
- The mind is nothing but a thought and the body is nothing but extension and we know this to be true because of our clear and distinct ideas.
- Descartes Indivisibilty
- If two things are identical, then they cannot have different properties, however the mind and body do - the mind had thought and the body has extension.
- Descartes claims that extension is the essential property of physical objects and what is extended is divisible.
- Something as small as a wave of light cannot be divided, but this is a fundamental part of the universe so it must be physical
- Descartes claims that extension is the essential property of physical objects and what is extended is divisible.
- The body is spatially divisible and the mind is not. You can divide the body into pieces but the mind you cannot.
- Many physical properties aren't divisible e.g. being able to fly is a property of a bird, but this cannot be divided. Only spatial properties are spatially divisible. Therefore bodies could possess mental properties.
- The mind and body have a very close relationship.
- Liebniz and his principle of the indiscernibly of identicals supports this: if two things are identical (one and the same) then they share all the same properties.
- If two things are identical, then they cannot have different properties, however the mind and body do - the mind had thought and the body has extension.
- Key terms
- The divisibility argument only succeeds if we assume that the mind is a substance.
- If the only substance in existence is matter then there are no minds - only the mental properties of our brain (grey matter).
Comments
No comments have yet been made