Select Committees

  • Created by: Q_
  • Created on: 31-03-19 11:48
View mindmap
  • Are select committees effective in scrutinising the executive?
    • NO
      • A government with a majority in the Commons will also have a majority in the committees.
      • Ministers and civil servants may not provide much information when questioned, and access to documents may be denied.
      • They have no power to propose policy - governmentscan ignore recommendations made by select committees.
      • Some members do not attend regularly; some may be overly abrasive when questioning witnesses.
    • YES
      • Select committees scrutinise the policies and actions of government, conducting detailed examinations of controversial issues.
      • They question ministers, civil servants and outside experts, and can request access to government papers.
      • Many select committee recommendations are accepted by the government.
      • The election of chairs and members by mPs has enhanced the independeneof select committees.


No comments have yet been made

Similar Government & Politics resources:

See all Government & Politics resources »See all The legislative branch of the US government resources »