Definitions of miracles

HideShow resource information
View mindmap
  • Definitions of Miracles
    • In a theological context, there is a disagreement about what a miracle actually is
      • There are 3 different definitions and categories of miracles:
        • 1. A common definition of a miracle is one which conforms to two principles
          • 1st principle: It must be completely different/strange of our understanding of the laws of nature.
            • Swinburne defined miracles as 'impossible' events that change how we understand natural laws
          • 2nd principle: It must have a purpose and religious significance. S.E.Evans agreed with this
            • S.E.Evans stated that "obviously the miracles of a religion, such as Christianity are not merely bizarre events or stunts. They have a function and purpose and usually that function is a revelatory one".
        • 2. Thomas Aquinas produced a different definition which involved 3 categories of miracles:
          • 1. Events that could never happen naturally and can only be brought about by God
          • 2. Events that could happen naturally, but only God could have brought it about in that particular order or timescale
          • 3. Events that happen naturally but God does not use natural laws
        • 3. There is an alternative definition in which there are 3 principles involved:
          • 1. Events which break with the laws of nature, e.g. walking on water
          • 2. An improbability, e.g. spring suddenly appearing
          • 3. A coincidence, e.g. praying for rain and it starts raining
    • There are other philosophers that have different opinions on what a miracle is:
      • Paul Tillich: "an event which is astonishing, unusual, shaking and without contradicting the rational structure of reality... an event which points to the mystery of being."
      • John Macquarrie: "a miracle is an event that excites wonder... it is believed that God is in the event in some special way... and intends to achieve some special end by it."
      • R.F.Holland defines a miracle as an extraordinary coincidence that is interpreted as having religious significance. It depends on how witnesses interpret it, rather on the nature of the miracle itself or if a natural law is broken
      • A controversial definition has been put forward by Brian Davies
        • Brian Davies: described a miracle as "unexpected and fortuitous events in the light of which we are disposed to give thanks to God." This definition includes 'lucky coincidences'.

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Philosophy resources:

See all Philosophy resources »See all Miracles resources »