• Created by: Q_
  • Created on: 09-06-19 19:05
View mindmap
  • Do liberals have a coherent view of the state?
    • NO
      • The liberal state supposedly supports foundational equality, in which all individuals are treated equally.Yet the liberal state was slow to adopt the principles of democracy, sexual equality and universal suffrage.
      • The liberal state extols the natural right to property. But it fails to recognise that most individuals under the state's jurisdiction have not owned property.
      • The liberal state defends 'government by consent', yet its constitution allows the consent of a majority to sometimes be defied via courts and assorted 'checks and balances'.
      • The liberal state is supposed to be 'limited', yet modern liberals have advocated a significant extension of the state intervention in the name of 'positive liberty'.
      • Modern liberals have compromised their belief in 'government by consent', by supporting supranational bodies like the EU, which arguably erode the authority of elective parliaments and elected representatives.
    • YES
      • Liberals are optimistic, believing that human beings are rational. Liberals believe in a constitutional state - drawn up as a result of rational discussion.
      • Liberal philosophers like Locke speak of a 'natural society' in which all individuals enjoy 'natural rights'. It is therefore coherent for liberals to support a 'limited state' that embodies such natural advantages via mechanisms such as a bill of rights.
      • The liberal state was a reaction against the medieval state in which power was concentrated in the monarch. The liberal state should be one with enhanced power dispersal.


No comments have yet been made

Similar Government & Politics resources:

See all Government & Politics resources »See all Liberalism resources »