Goodness of God criticisms

HideShow resource information
View mindmap
  • Goodness of God criticisms
    • J.L.Mackie
      • Inconsistent triad- god is omnibenevolent and omnipotent yet evil still exists
    • Hume
      • What conclusions do you draw about the designer of a house if it falls?
    • Aquinas
      • Can we talk about God's goodness in a meaningful fashion? Is God's nature unknowable?
    • Does God responding to human needs and requests mean that God is not perfect?
    • God is not like a human designer and so comparisons are invalid
    • Natural evil is a consequences of the laws of nature which enable change and development
    • Epistemic distance
    • The problem of evil
    • What conclusions could be drawn about God because of Natural Evil?
    • Plato
      • Euthyphro dilemma- are things good because God  says they're good? (Arbitrary) or are they good within themselves (not omnipotent)
    • The bible
      • Miracle at Ai-God stops the sun and all men, women and children are killed by the Jews
      • God remains faithful to the cevenant- Hebrew slaves in Egypt are set free
      • Healing miracles- naaman's leprosy and lazareth being resurrected
      • Jesus and sacrificial death which saved humanity from consequences of its sin and enables humanity to reconnect with God
      • Threw Adam and Eve out of the garden of Eden resulting in mortality for humans, painful childbirth for women and men having to work from the land

Comments

No comments have yet been made

Similar Philosophy resources:

See all Philosophy resources »See all Goodness of God/God as Creator resources »