Falsification
Mind map on the three philiosophers interpretations of Falsification
- Created by: JMitch
- Created on: 29-05-13 13:33
View mindmap
- Falsification
- Anthony Flew
- Analogy of Explorers in a Jungle
- 1 explorer argues that the Jungle must have a Gardener
- The other is a skeptic and watches and can't see it - the believer qualifies it as an invisible gardener
- They set traps and electric fences but still the believer does not give-in
- The Believer argues that the gardener is invisible, intangible and insensible - the Skeptic argues that it is no different to a made up gardener or no gardener at all
- Flew called this 'Death by a Thousand Qualifications'
- Religious believers dismiss any evidence to falsify their faith and therefore making their faith meaningless as unfalsifiable
- Analogy of Explorers in a Jungle
- R.M. Hare
- Parable of the Paranoid Man
- Lunatic student believed that all lecturers were trying to kill him
- Despite many good natured lecturers being shown to falsify the belief, the lunatic argued they were trying to trick him
- A sane student wouldn't have had this - the paranoid man represenst the bilk
- Agreed with Flew but argued that people have different standards of falsification
- These different standards are called Bilks - a set of beliefs that will not change
- Religious believers have an unfalsifiable bilk
- Argued Flew was wrong to treat religion like science
- But Flew argued that religious believers make statements about creation, therefroe needing to be treated in a scientific way
- Parable of the Paranoid Man
- Basil Mitchell
- Story of the Stranger
- A partisan met a stranger who told the partisan to trust him no matter what
- When the stranger is seen helping the cause, the partisan declares he is on our side
- Also declares the stranger is on their side when arresting partisans
- Friends ask what the stranger would need to do for the partisan to change his mind - he gives no replies
- Mitchell argues that religious believers recognise issues such as the Problem of Evil, but it doesn't affect their belief
- Flew argued that if you questioned believers on the issue they would eventually qualify their belief or God
- Story of the Stranger
- Religious believers accept no possibility of falsification in regards of God - this is therefore meaningless
- Criticisms
- Swinburne Toys in Toy cupboard
- Ayer argues that a unicorn who comes out when no-one looks is technically possible with this theory
- Anthony Flew
Comments
No comments have yet been made