eternal god & free will

HideShow resource information
View mindmap
    • if god knows our choices we are not free; we cannot choose another action as God cannot be mistaken for he is perfect
      • view that our choices are contingent is false- instead they are necessary meaning our future is set
    • In response to the criticism: Boethius- god does not know the future, he simply knows everything. he knows what is true but is unaware of which time/place in history events take place
      • god sees everything simultaneously
      • Analogy of the Road: when walking along a road we are unaware of who is behind us however someone who sees the whole road from a height is able to see everyone travelling the path. walker is making choices and the person looking down (god) can see what choices we will make
        • this knowledge is not causal thus humans have free will
        • Augustine: god simply knows our choices
        • analogy adopted by Aquinas (Summa Theologiae)
    • Anthony Kenny: god knowing all time is incoherent as it proposes that all time is happening within the same moment: uses example of him typing his paper (The God of Philosophers) occurring at the same time as the great fire of Rome
      • Paul Helm: we should abandon the idea that eternity involves events being simultaneously present to god
        • god is timeless- what humans are doing is not taking place at the same time anything god is doing. suggests god cannot have temporal relations to any of his creation


No comments have yet been made

Similar Religious Studies resources:

See all Religious Studies resources »