HideShow resource information
  • Created by: rachel
  • Created on: 18-05-13 11:27
View mindmap
  • Deterence
    • Reductivist (Utilitarian) approach
    • Can this justify prison?
    • People in the riots got 4 years for "inciting disorder via facebook"
      • Lack of consistency across offences - sexual assault and death by drink driving have similar average sentences
      • To make an example of them but interviews with rioters said "we'll steal more/do more next time to make the punishment worth it"
    • There are a lot of factors that influence offenders, e.g. addiction and therefore they may not always consider the punishment
    • There is an expectation that life in prison should be worse than the life for the lowest class of individuals
      • BBC documentary: some offenders think prison is better - gets them drug help quicker and don't have to worry about food etc
      • Roof over head, food and gets to learn skills etc.
    • Many offenders think "I wont get caught"
    • From Bentham onwards - distinction between individual and general detterence.
      • Deterring the offender from offending again. Individual Deterrence.
        • Boot camps don't work - Wilson
        • 'Three strikes and you're out' = little evidence on significant impact on crime Zimring.
          • Someone got a life sentence for his third strike which was stealing a slice of pizza (changed on appeal as unfair - shows it doesn't work)
        • Weisburd: white collar crime - few differences in re arrest rates for those who had been imprisoned and those who hadn't
        • Chambliss: made clear the punishment of parking offences, violation reduced.
      • Deterring other people from committing offences. General Deterrence
        • Hirsch: Who decides how severe a punishment needs to be to deter others? Are we deterred by different things? What about offences with a large degree of emotion? Will the people you're trying to deter, know about the punishment just given?
        • Beyleveld: unless you violate human rights, general deterrence policy will not control the crime rate.
      • Bentham ' The punishment suffered by the offender presents to every one an example of what he himself will have to suffer, if he is guilty of the same offence'


No comments have yet been made

Similar resources:

See all resources »