Individual Differences - Approaches to abnormality and evaluation points
- Created by: Matt H
- Created on: 20-10-12 15:28
Psychodynamic approach - background
- Put forward by Sigmund Freud in the late 19th Century
- Key assumption is that all human behaviour can be explained in terms of inner mind conflict
- The mind structure is made up of the conscious (where all conscious thinking takes place) and the unconscious (where hidden thoughts and feelings are found)
- Freud said that successful psychosexual development is essential for a healthy personality
- Through each of the three stages of development (oral, anal and phallic), personality develops in the form of the id, ego and superego.
- He believed these were separate conflicting forces, requiring a balance in mental health for a normal lifestyle.
Psychodynamic approach - the id, ego and superego
The id
- We are born with the id
- Its energy is called the libido
- Operates on the pleasure principle - "I want"
The ego
- Operates on the reality principle - "Think about it"
- Balances the drives of the id and superego
- Children begin to learn they're individuals and can't always get what they want through toddlerhood
- They recognise their own desires, wants and needs forming the ego
The superego
- Operates on the morality principle - "It is wrong to"
- Includes understanding of right and wrong
- The ideal force - the figure the individual strives to be
- Opposes the id
Psychodynamic approach - defence mechanisms
Freud said that when things go wrong in our lives that we can't deal with, we develop defence mechanisms such as:
- Repression - (burying) of the problem into our unconscious
- Denial - of the problem
- Projection - projecting our problem behaviour onto someone else
- Displacement - our problems are channelled into other things such as eating
- Regression - we go back several stages in our personality development
Psychodynamic approach - evaluation points
- Provides some believable explanations but lacks empirical research evidence
- Freud based his ideas mainly on analysis of middle class Viennese women
- He only studied one child (Little Hans) when developing his theories and he only corresponded with the child's father, not the boy himself
- His theories were revolutionary for the time they were developed as they suggested that abnormality could be caused by things other than medical issues or evil spirits
- They also paved the way for other models to be developed, such as the behavioural and cognitive model
- There is much evidence suggesting that adult disorders can be caused by childhood trauma, despite a lack of scientific evidence
- The theory tends to over focus on sexual issues and ignores the importance of interpersonal and social factors in causing abnormality
- The psychodynamic approach is determinist, as it says suffering childhood trauma will lead to abnormal behaviour in adulthood
- It ignores the influence of genes, reward and thinking patterns
Cognitive approach - background
- The approach perceives mental disorders as negative thoughts and illogical beliefs
- Beck's cognitive triad:
- The three illogical thought processes of the triad cause irrational negative feelings about self - called "cognitive errors"
- Ellis (1962) suggested the A-B-C model for diagnosing abnormality:
A - Activating event
B - Belief which may be rational or irrational
C - Consequence, rational beliefs lead to healthy emotions and irrational beliefs lead to unhealthy emotions
Cognitive approach - evaluation points
+ It empowers individuals with the ability to change cognitions
+ Research suggests that faulty thought processes and abnormality is linked
+ The approach allows for free will as it takes into account decision making and choices
+ It is high in validity and reliability
- The cognitive approach places the blame for abnormality on the patient
- Faulty thinking may not be the cause, but a symptom of something else
Behaviourist approach - background
- J.B. Watson - "Father of Behaviourism" (Little Albert)
- Focusses on the role of the environment in individual development
- Tabula Rasa - theory that we are born as a blank slate and our environment determines how we turn out
- Uses stimulus-response relationships
- Cl***ical conditioning - learning through ***ociation
Neutral Stimulus (NS) --> No response
Unconditioned Stimulus (UCS) --> Unconditioned Response (UCR)
Conditioned Stimulus (CS) + Unconditioned Stimulus (UCS) --> Conditioned Response (CR) - Operant conditioning - learning through consequence, focusses on reward and punishment
- Reinforcement - anything increasing the likelihood of repeated behaviour.
- Positive reinforcement - reinforcement using pleasant consequences when they happen
- Negative reinforcement - reinforcement using pleasant consequences when they stop
- Punishment - anything unpleasant decreasing the likelihood of repeated behaviour
- Continuous reinforcement - the desired behaviour is reinforced every time it occurs
- Partial reinforcement - the response is reinforced only part of the time
- Vicarious reinforcement - reinforcement from seeing others rewarded and punished
Behaviourist approach - evaluation points
+ Does explain the role of the media and its influences - Becker (1999)
+ Proven results
+ Uses observable behaviour - evidence that can be seen
- Some phobics can't remember a neutral stimulus, which could suggest not all phobias are behavioural
- Disorders like schizophrenia are hard to explain in terms of the behaviourist approach
- It is very simplistic and reductionist
- Lots of research is conducted on animals
- Determinist - reinforced behaviour WILL be carried out, no free will
Biological approach - background
- The cause of a disorder - think BING:
- Brain injury
- Infection
- Neurotransmitters
- Genetics - Genetics - individuals may inherit certain disorders from relatives, especially parents
- Abnormal behaviour could be as a result of an individual's biochemistry:
- Neurotransmitters may contribute to disorders
- Schizophrenia - excessive amounts of dopamine
- Bi-polar depression - high levels of serotonin - Neuroanatomy - the structure of the nervous system may be involved in some disorders
- Post-mortem schizophrenics have enlarged ventricles in the brain
Biological approach - evaluation points
+ Medical evidence
+ Scientific proof and explanations
+ Most reliable tests - replicable with the same results
+ No blame
- Reductionist
- Genetics don't provide complete explanation
- Drugs don't always work
- Physical irregularities may be symptoms not causes
- Might cause patients to become passive/dependant on treatment/doctor
- Focusses on curing symptoms, not the causes
- Some ethical/moral issues
Related discussions on The Student Room
- Psychology 4 Mark Questions »
- Need help with A level psychology 16 marker! »
- Cie a level 9990 psychology A level »
- A-level Literature poetry comparison essay »
- A level psychology help »
- AQA A-level Psychology Paper 1 (7182/1) - 19th May 2023 [Exam Chat] »
- cancer or paranoid »
- gcse aqa drama devising log »
- Module selection (psychology ) »
- Does having a cold sore mean you’ll get cervical cancer? »
Comments
No comments have yet been made